The Stanford Review
4 Comments

The Church vs. Obamacare

The recent conflict between the Catholic Church and the Obama administration came to a head when various Catholic institutions across the country filed a federal lawsuit against the Obama contraception mandate.  The United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) had been threatening to sue after the Obama administration failed to come up with a satisfactory compromise to its initial contraception mandate.

The mandate would require employers to provide workers with birth control coverage.  The Catholic Church teaches that artificial contraception is immoral; thus a mandate compelling employers to provide contraceptives infringes upon the religious freedom of Catholic employers.

In response, the Obama administration composed a compromise that allowed exceptions for religious groups, but instead shifted the requirement of providing contraceptives to insurance companies.  Of course, the US bishops were not at all placated by this failure to address the issue, and lawsuits from dioceses in eight states and the District of Columbia were subsequently filed.  Indeed, many religiously affiliated institutions would have to shut down, including the large number of Catholic hospitals and many Catholic charities, if the mandate were to be carried through.

This issue has become relevant in the Stanford community in recent weeks, as events such as the “Leading, Mobilizing and Funding the Reproductive Rights Movement for the 21st Century” and the “Pro-Life, Pro-Family Reception” have attracted many student attendees.  For Catholic students in particular, it has become readily apparent that they will have to choose sides, and no longer be ambivalent towards the issue, as their Church and religion are being directly attacked.

The US Bishops led by Cardinal Dolan of New York have made the official stance of the Catholic Church abundantly clear: they cannot in any way support the use of artificial contraception, and therefore cannot support President Obama’s mandate.  Thus, by forcing Catholics to do it anyway infringes upon their religious freedom.

The issue has been seen to cause commotion at other universities already, including Georgetown University.  The Jesuit school invited Kathleen Sebelius, the secretary for Health and Human Services, the organization which would be adopting the Obama mandate, to make a graduation speech.  The university made the press when Cardinal Wuerl and other Catholic leaders spoke out in criticism of the selection.

At Stanford too, things are rapidly coming to a head between the push for the mandate and the Catholics whose religious freedom is being chipped away.  The US bishops have encouraged Catholics everywhere to become aware of the issue and to support the Church in the defense of Her religious freedom.  Catholics at Stanford can start on campus, where they can raise awareness for the issue and courageously stand up for what their faith teaches despite whatever opposition may confront them.

Several religious groups have shown their support for the Catholics’ unwavering stance, and it has become a rallying point for Conservatives of all kinds of religious backgrounds who oppose Obamacare.  President Obama’s mistake of ignoring the religious liberty of the Catholic Church will prove fatal as the powerful institution and Conservative groups across the country are joining together to defeat Obamacare once and for all.

About the author:
Has 8 Articles

  • Non-catholic

    I don’t understand the reason behind the mandate. Are birth controls that expensive that people cannot buy for themselves?

  • Bill regan

    the catholic church will Lose a great deal of their dwindling authority among members if it doesn’t revolt against Obamacare. It must get a publicity campaign in motion and do everything in it’s power to broadcast the abuse of religious freedom. The only thing the president understands is votes. He needs to feel the pressure of a unified catholic population and all other people who recognize that they too may literally participate in violation of their morals . The church is doing a very poor job to date in getting this issue front and center

  • Catholic Dad
  • madeline hartmann

    So how many Catholics are following the church’s teaching on birth control?
    If a c hurch can control what people eat and their sex life, it has real control.
    What is the real issue? Is it as some suggest to control women? If they have a baby every 10 months,they certainly cannot enter the public world> Is this the old German KKK?
    Over population? remenger that one?

Back to Top